Which number does not belong: 12, 16, 18, or 24? More than one answer can work—but only if the evidence fits all four numbers.

I can use number properties as evidence so I can defend a mathematical claim.
- I name one precise property.
- I test it against all four numbers.
- I show a calculation or factor evidence.
Your core challenge · 5–10 minutes
- Which one number does not belong, and what exact property makes it different from all three others?
- What factor, multiplication fact, or calculation proves your claim?
Sentence starter: “___ does not belong because it is the only number that ___. I checked this by ___.”
Use properties as evidence
A strong answer does more than point to a number that looks different. It names a property—a mathematical feature that can be checked. A factor divides a number with no remainder. A number is divisible by another number when the quotient is a whole number. A perfect square is made by multiplying a whole number by itself, such as 25 = 5 × 5.
Test your rule against every number. If you claim one number is the only multiple of 5, you must show that it is a multiple of 5 and the other three are not. A calculation, factor list, or definition makes the reasoning verifiable. “It has different factors” is too vague because every number has its own factor list.
This kind of problem may have several correct claims. That does not mean every answer is correct. The property must separate exactly one number from the other three in this set.
Worked example · A different number set
Claim: 16 does not belong because it is the only number not divisible by 5.
Evidence: 10 ÷ 5 = 2, 15 ÷ 5 = 3, and 20 ÷ 5 = 4. Each quotient is a whole number. But 16 ÷ 5 = 3.2, so 16 is not divisible by 5.
The example uses a different set, so you still need to investigate 12, 16, 18, and 24 yourself.
Optional stretch challenge
Defend a second answer for 12, 16, 18, and 24 using a different property. Check that the new rule still separates exactly one number.
Check and revise
Too vague
“16 is different because it has different factors.”
More precise
“16 does not belong because it is the only perfect square. It equals 4 × 4; 12, 18, and 24 are not whole numbers multiplied by themselves.”
If your property also fits a second number, narrow the property or choose a different claim. Before submitting, ask: “Did I test all four numbers, and could another student verify my evidence?”
Post one claim and its evidence in the comments, or use your teacher’s assigned response space. Then reply to a classmate by checking the property against all four numbers. For another way to make thinking visible, explore the math learning pathways or the Math Arcade.


